How To Buy the Right Water Filters

January 9, 2018by Mike Gable
How To Buy the Right Water Filters

The right water filter is the one that removes what is actually in your water, at the flow your home needs, in the place it does the most good. That means testing first, then matching the filter to the result, not buying the biggest unit on the shelf and hoping it covers everything.

Call 215-322-6884, 24/7 Request a free quote

Key Takeaways

  • Test the water first: city water and well water carry different contaminants.
  • Carbon filters cut chlorine and taste and odor; they do not remove hardness, lead, or bacteria on their own.
  • Reverse osmosis removes the widest range, but it treats one tap, not the whole house.
  • A whole-house filter protects every tap; a point-of-use filter protects one.
  • Each American uses about 82 gallons of water a day at home, according to the USGS, so size the system for real daily use.
  • Filters need new cartridges on schedule, or they stop working and can let contaminants through.

Start with a water test

A filter bought without a test is a guess, and guesses miss. City water is treated and tested by the supplier, and its report shows what is in it. Well water is the owner’s job to test, and it should be tested regularly, because what is in it can change. Either way, the test result is the shopping list: chlorine and taste call for carbon, hardness calls for a softener, sediment calls for a sediment filter, and lead or bacteria call for a filter certified for that contaminant.

Test for the full picture, not one thing. A basic test covers hardness, chlorine, iron, sediment, pH, and bacteria, and a lead test is worth adding in an older home with older pipes. The result also sets the size: a household that uses more water needs a bigger system, and a filter that is too small for the flow will clog early and starve the taps.

Filter types, matched to the job

No single filter does everything, so match the type to the contaminant.

Filter type What it removes Best for
Pitcher filter Chlorine taste and odor, some particles Drinking water for one person, on a budget
Faucet-mount filter Chlorine taste and odor at one tap Renters and single-tap drinking water
Under-sink carbon Chlorine, taste, odor, and some chemicals Drinking and cooking water at the kitchen tap
Reverse osmosis The widest range: dissolved solids, lead, and more Drinking water where the test shows a real problem
Whole-house carbon Chlorine and odor at every tap Every tap, shower, and appliance in the home
Water softener Hardness minerals, not contaminants Hard water: scale, spots, and stiff laundry

Every gallon passes through your filter: U.S. Geological Survey figures

One person a day at home: about 82 gallons

A family of four a day at home: more than 300 gallons

Source: U.S. Geological Survey, via U.S. EPA WaterSense, Statistics and Facts. Each American uses an average of 82 gallons of water a day at home, and the average family uses more than 300 gallons a day.

Whole-house or point-of-use

Test the water → Match the filter to the result → Choose whole-house or point-of-use → Have it installed with a shut-off and a bypass → Change cartridges on schedule.

The choice comes down to where the problem lives. If chlorine taste bothers you at every tap and in the shower, a whole-house filter treats the water where it enters the home. If only the drinking water needs work, an under-sink or reverse osmosis unit at the kitchen tap does the job for less. Many homes end up with both: a whole-house filter for taste and odor, and a point-of-use unit for drinking water.

Installation matters as much as the filter. A shut-off valve and a bypass let the system be serviced without cutting water to the house, and the unit needs to sit where cartridges can be reached and changed. A plumber fits all of that as part of the install, and sizes the unit to the home’s real flow so showers and appliances never starve.

Never fit a filter to treat water you suspect is unsafe without a test first. A filter cannot be trusted to fix water that smells of fuel or chemicals, or well water after a flood. Stop drinking it, get it tested, and let the result decide what treatment is needed. And never drink from a filter whose cartridge is past its change date.

Why homeowners in two counties call Central

  • Tested, not guessed: the water is tested first, so the filter matches what is actually in it.
  • Installed by licensed plumbers: shut-off valves and bypasses fitted as standard, sized to the home’s real flow.
  • One visit covers the system: filtration, softening, and leak checks from the same technicians.
  • Cartridges on a schedule: a maintenance plan keeps filters changed on time, so they keep working.
  • Clear pricing up front: the quote is agreed in writing before the install starts, and the estimate itself costs nothing.
  • Help whenever it is needed: the phones are answered around the clock, and a technician is usually on site within 60 minutes.

More from the same team: Plumbing Services, Remodeling Services.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a water test before buying a filter?

Yes. Without a test you may buy a filter that misses the actual contaminant in your water. The test shows what needs removing, and that decides the filter type, the size, and whether you need one unit or two.

Will a water softener filter my water?

No. A softener removes hardness minerals that cause scale and spots, but it does not remove chlorine, lead, or bacteria. Many homes with hard water need both: a softener for hardness and a filter for taste and contaminants.

Whole-house or under-sink: which is better?

It depends on the problem. Whole-house treats every tap and shower, which suits chlorine taste and odor throughout the home. Under-sink or reverse osmosis treats one tap, which suits drinking water where the test shows a specific problem. Many homes use both.

How often do filter cartridges need changing?

Follow the maker’s schedule, which is usually every few months for small cartridges and once a year for larger ones. A cartridge past its date stops working and can let trapped contaminants back into the water, so the schedule is part of the filter, not an optional extra.

Can a filter remove lead?

Only a filter certified for lead removal. Check for NSF/ANSI 53 certification for lead, not the claims on the box. If the test shows lead, a certified filter or a reverse osmosis unit at the drinking tap is the right answer.

Call 215-322-6884, 24/7

Central Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning
Based at 950 Industrial Blvd, Southampton, PA 18966
+1 215 322 6884
help@cmcmail.net
Day or night, the phone is answered by someone who can send help.

Bucks County Service Areas & Montgomery County Service Areas

Bristol | Chalfont | Churchville | Doylestown | Dublin | Feasterville | Holland | Hulmeville | Huntington Valley | Ivyland | Langhorne & Langhorne Manor | New Britain & New Hope | Newtown | Penndel | Perkasie | Philadelphia | Quakertown | Richlandtown | Ridgeboro | Southampton | Trevose | Tullytown | Warrington | Warminster & Yardley | Arcadia University | Ardmore | Blue Bell | Bryn Mawr | Flourtown | Fort Washington | Gilbertsville | Glenside | Haverford College | Horsham | King of Prussia | Maple Glen | Montgomeryville | Oreland | Plymouth Meeting | Skippack | Spring House | Stowe | Willow Grove | Wyncote & Wyndmoor
Mike Gable

Mike Gable

Mike Gable is the founder and owner of Central Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning, proudly serving Bucks and Montgomery County since 2001.

With over two decades of hands-on experience, Mike’s mission has always been simple: deliver honest, high-quality service that homeowners and business owners can count on—day or night.

Through every blog post, Mike shares practical advice, expert insight, and a commitment to helping his community stay safe, comfortable, and confident in their home systems.

CLICK TO CALL GET A QUOTE TEXT US 💬